Catastrophizing and Decatastrophizing: A Comprehensive Guide

If your imagination has ever run amok, dragging you through a repeat cycle of worst possible scenarios, then you likely understand the concept of ‘catastrophizing.’

This negative mental schema serves to magnify thoughts and situations such that they are blown way out of proportion with reality. This article will discuss what it means to catastrophize, its negative impact on emotional wellbeing, and how to use cognitive restructuring as a way to decatastrophize negative thinking.

Numerous examples are included, along with helpful books and resources from PositivePsychology.com. So, let’s get started on embracing a more positive and realistic mindset that enhances empowerment, self-control, and optimism.

Before you continue, we thought you might like to download our three Positive CBT Exercises for free. These science-based exercises will provide you with detailed insight into Positive CBT and give you the tools to apply it in your therapy or coaching.

What Is Catastrophizing?

Catastrophizing is a big word for making a mountain out of a molehill.

It’s a cognitive distortion in which a situation is overblown and/or future expectations are considered bleak. Albert Ellis – noted cognitive psychologist specializing in Rational-Emotive Therapy – first coined the term, describing catastrophizing as experiencing “an irrationally negative forecast of future events” (Quartana, Campbell, & Edwards, 2009, p. 745).

Individuals who catastrophize become anxious as they overestimate the probability of a poor outcome. While we all experience disappointments, a catastrophizer might perceive a setback (e.g., failing a test) as the end of the world.

Catastrophizing is not pleasant, as it involves extensive and irrational worry over what might happen in the future. Sometimes individuals catastrophize as a way of protecting themselves from getting hurt. For example, catastrophizers may consciously or unconsciously believe that by only expecting the absolute worst, they will be less hurt or disappointed if things go wrong.

However, like seeing a glass as half empty, the catastrophizer’s viewpoint is pessimistic and uninspiring. Because this type of negativistic thinking reduces a person’s likelihood of taking reasonable and important risks (e.g., looking for a new job, traveling, committing to a partner, etc.), the ultimate outcome of catastrophizing is to shield oneself from some of life’s most meaningful and joyous experiences.

15 Examples of Catastrophizing

The catastrophizing literature is highly skewed toward health-related topics, as catastrophizers often perceive medical concerns and expectations of pain as far worse than reality.

Consequently, catastrophizing exacerbates medical issues through its relationship with increased pain severity and sensitivity, affective distress, and muscle tenderness, as well as poorer treatment outcomes (Edwards, Bingham, Bathon, & Haythornthwaite, 2006).

Other areas where individuals often blow things out of proportion include family, relationships, safety, and vanity – among others.

Here are 15 examples:

1. Not getting hired following a job interview is expected to result in the inability to attain a job at all, ultimately resulting in poverty and homelessness.
2. Giving a class presentation is expected to cause embarrassment and failure, leading a student to never show their face at school again.
3. Receiving a shot from the doctor is expected to be so overwhelming that it will result in fainting.
4. The end of a romantic relationship is perceived to mean that a person is unlovable.
5. A parent perceives a child’s skinned knee as suggesting that the playground is a far too dangerous place for the child to play.
6. A person gets a pimple and believes everyone sees them as ugly.
7. After breaking their diet for a cookie, a person believes they are a total failure at dieting and destined to be overweight forever.
8. After experiencing consistent headaches over the course of a week, a person believes they are suffering from a brain tumor.
9. After a food poisoning incident, a person believes all restaurants are dangerous and associated with terrible health outcomes.
10. The belief that riding on a boat is dangerous because it is sure to sink, causing all passengers to drown.
11. A new driver experiences a fender-bender and decides never to drive again because they will always be a terrible driver.
12. Messing up a special dinner is perceived as indicating that a person is a terrible cook and can’t do anything right.
13. A jogger trips over a rock and decides they are uncoordinated and that continued running is likely to result in serious injury.
14. A child watches a scary movie and becomes convinced that it will come true.
15. After hearing about a shark attack on the other side of the world, a person believes it’s unsafe to set foot in the ocean.

Its Role in Anxiety and Depression

While the catastrophizing literature is dominated by medical studies, the concept of catastrophizing was originally introduced by Beck, Rush, Shaw, and Embry (1978) as related to depression and anxiety. Beck et al. posited that individuals who are vulnerable to anxiety experience cognitive distortions in which threats of negative outcomes are overestimated and coping skills for dealing with adversity are underestimated.

Research has supported the ideas of Beck et al., as a catastrophizing cognitive schema has been linked to psychological distress independent of the degree of physical impairment (Severeijns, Vlaeyen, Van den Hout, & Weber, 2001). While worrying does serve an adaptive function – that is, to prepare us for danger – catastrophizing operates at another level.

Since catastrophizing involves ruminating about terrible things that have a low probability of happening, such worry is wasted negative energy that erodes emotional wellbeing.

Not surprisingly, because it basically involves overblown and unrealistic anxiety about future threats, catastrophizing is related to anxiety disorders. For example, inherent in a diagnosis of generalized anxiety disorder is the tendency to ruminate over ‘what if’ questions, which is a counterproductive endeavor (Hazlett-Stevens & Craske, 2003).

Research indeed supports the relationship between catastrophizing and anxiety disorders, short- and long-term depressive affect, and increased pain and debilitation among those suffering from pain-related conditions (Asmundson, Vlaeyen, & Crombez, 2004; Edwards et al., 2006; Moore, Adams, Ellis, Thibault, & Sullivan, 2016).

Catastrophizing among children and teens

Catastrophizing, which may be learned at an early age, has negative implications for both adults and young people. For example, research has indicated that catastrophizing about the consequences of sleeplessness is associated with increased sleep disturbances among children (Gregory, Noone, Eley, & Harvey, 2010).

Sleep-related catastrophizing appears to be common among kids, with Gregory et al. (2010) reporting this behavior among one in four of the children in their sample.

Importantly, the authors also noted that the relationship between catastrophizing and children’s sleep problems was explained by symptoms of depression and anxiety (Gregory et al., 2010). In another study examining catastrophic thinking among kids, a significant link between catastrophizing and depression was found among third-grade children (Noël, Francis, Williams-Outerbridge, & Fung, 2012).

Similarly, in a large sample of adolescents with high anxiety, the roles of catastrophizing and daily hassles in anxiety were examined (Chan, Chan, & Kwok, 2015). The authors reported a significant link between catastrophizing and anxiety. Interestingly, the effect of daily hassles on anxiety was mediated by catastrophizing.

In other words, while experiencing daily hassles was a predictor of increased anxiety, such stressors increased anxiety via the adolescents’ catastrophizing (Chan et al., 2015).

Clearly, investigating a link between catastrophizing and depression and anxiety gets a little messy, as research examining depression requires careful control of anxiety and vice versa.

Additionally, relationships between concepts such as stress and anxiety or depression are often mediated by catastrophic thinking. While more research is sorely needed in catastrophizing and mental health outcomes, extant research suggests that catastrophic thinking enhances depressive and anxious symptomatology among adults, teens, and children.

You largely constructed your depression. It wasn’t given to you. Therefore, you can deconstruct it.

Albert Ellis

Decatastrophizing and Cognitive Restructuring

Catastrophizing is not a healthy mindset.

Fortunately, such nonadaptive cognitive schemas may be broken down and modified in a way that is more conducive to positive outcomes (i.e., cognitive restructuring).

Used as part of Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy (CBT), cognitive restructuring involves examining one’s thought processes and beliefs about an actual or potential situation. As outlined by Hope, Burns, Hayes, and Warner (2010), cognitive restructuring involves the following four steps:

1. Identification of dysfunctional automatic thoughts
2. Identification of cognitive distortions
3. Disputing automatic thoughts
4. Creating rational rebuttal to automatic thoughts

Following this approach, a therapist will work with a client to examine dysfunctional appraisals of situations (e.g., “I’m a loser because I didn’t get an ‘A’ on my test.”) and replace them with more functional ones (e.g., “Not getting an ‘A’ on my test is not the end of the world and doesn’t define who I am as a person.”). This process often involves role-playing to simulate situations such that potential threats are viewed as realistic and manageable.

Taking on a more optimistic and less self-deprecating perspective increases empowerment, self-efficacy, and self-worth, which, in turn, enhances positive emotional wellbeing.

Although it’s an important therapeutic tool, anyone may use cognitive restructuring as a way of breaking down catastrophic thinking and building positive appraisals to use instead – decatastrophizing. In doing so, an individual can see the sunny side of life and respond to challenges from a place of power rather than vulnerability.

10 Examples of Decatastrophizing

The following table presents 10 situations, along with a catastrophized and decatastrophized appraisal of each of them.

The table illustrates that decatastrophizing is a simple way to change negative appraisals of common events into ones that are healthier and more encouraging.

8 Decatastrophizing Resources

There are various resources available for those who wish to reduce catastrophic thinking. For example, the following books contain helpful, science-based strategies intended to help adults and teens to free themselves from the negative grasp of anxious thinking.

These books also contain valuable information and tools for therapists working with catastrophizing clients.

1. The Worry Cure: Seven Steps to Stop Worry From Stopping You – Robert L. Leahy

This book contains a seven-step program designed to help readers change their worry patterns.

It also aims to help them distinguish between productive and unproductive types of worry, take control of anxiety-promoting energy, identify prosocial opportunities, embrace certainty, and stop “safety behaviors” (i.e., doing things that make us feel momentarily safe, but ultimately leave us feeling worse).

Available on Amazon.

2. Feeling Great: The Revolutionary New Treatment for Depression and Anxiety – David D. Burns

This research-grounded book contains numerous case studies.

It also contains over 50 tools designed to eliminate the negative thinking that feeds depression.

Available on Amazon.

3. Don’t Feed the Monkey Mind: How to Stop the Cycle of Anxiety, Fear & Worry – Jennifer Shannon

This book contains information and exercises aimed at eliminating anxious thoughts.

Readers learn how to stop feeding the anxious “monkey mind” by applying techniques grounded in CBT, mindfulness, and Acceptance and Commitment Therapy.

Available on Amazon.

4. Overcoming Unwanted Intrusive Thoughts: A CBT-Based Guide to Getting Over Frightening, Obsessive, or Disturbing Thoughts – Sally M. Winston and Martin N. Seif

This book provides readers with evidence-based CBT tools found to help individuals cope with negative rumination.

Rather than trying to stop unwanted thoughts, readers learn that they are not alone and that there are effective ways of moving past intrusive and anxiety-provoking cognitions.

Available on Amazon.

5. Dare: The New Way to End Anxiety and Stop Panic Attacks – Barry McDonagh

This unique, science-based book describes the ‘Dare’ technique as a way of eliminating panic attacks, general anxiety, and intrusive thoughts.

The book helps readers face fears, enhance confidence, identify healthy supplements, enjoy better sleep, and live their best life. The book also contains a free app along with helpful audio recordings.

Available on Amazon.

6. Anxiety: Panicking About Panic: A Powerful, Self-help Guide for Those Suffering from an Anxiety or Panic Disorder – Joshua Fletcher

This self-help book aims to help individuals dealing with anxiety disorders (e.g., generalized anxiety disorder or panic disorder) or maladaptive health-focused ruminations.

Placing particular emphasis on anticipatory anxiety, the book contains a great deal of information, advice, and techniques designed to guide people in breaking free of excessive worry.

Available on Amazon.

7. Conquer Negative Thinking for Teens: A Workbook to Break the Nine Thought Habits That Are Holding You Back – Mary Karapetian Alvord and Anne McGrath

This workbook is designed to help adolescents learn how to recognize and reframe negative thought processes that promote anxiety, depression, and stress.

Teens are instructed on applying cognitive restructuring to target and modify nine particular negative thinking habits, such as the catastrophizing habit, the all-or-nothing habit, and the blaming habit.

Available on Amazon.

8. Treating Internalizing Disorders in Children and Adolescents: Core Techniques and Strategies – Douglas W. Nangle, David J. Hansen, Rachel L. Grover, Julie Newman Kingery, Cynthia Suveg, and Contributors

This comprehensive book describes 13 evidence-based techniques aimed at treating anxiety and mood disorders among adolescents.

It is designed for use by therapists and contains rationales, examples, and guidelines for implementing various CBT strategies (e.g., relaxation, exposure, self-monitoring, etc.).

Available on Amazon.

Relevant Resources from PositivePsychology.com

PositivePsychology.com represents a great source of information and help for catastrophizers.

For example, the article 16 Decatastrophizing Tools, Worksheets, and Role-Plays contains six decatastrophizing tips. It also includes 10 decatastrophizing worksheets and information regarding cognitive restructuring and role-plays as techniques for combating catastrophic thinking.

The Positive Psychology Toolkit© also offers various worksheets and exercises designed to aid individuals in conquering negative thinking. Here is an example:

This exercise is designed to help readers develop the ability to let go of problematic thoughts by practicing cognitive diffusion. The tool contains a mindfulness ‘Leaves on a Stream’ script, which takes readers through a meditation practice in which they use the imagery of leaves gently flowing down a stream. The goal is to allow difficult or negative thoughts to float on by without reacting to them.

After the exercise, readers are instructed to debrief on the experience by exploring further questions. The exercise’s underlying purpose is to allow individuals with negative thoughts, such as catastrophizing, to learn how to detach from such thoughts and no longer view them as absolute truths.

Another great free resource is the Decatastrophizing in Steps worksheet, which takes the reader through five progressive steps, to help them deconstruct a catastrophe.

The Challenging Catastrophic Thinking worksheet makes use of CBT to guide the reader in capturing the thought processes involved with catastrophic thinking.

And f you’re looking for even more science-based ways to help others through CBT, this collection contains 17 validated positive CBT tools for practitioners. Use them to help others overcome unhelpful thoughts and feelings and develop more positive behaviors.

A Take-Home Message

We all look toward the dark side from time to time. But when this rearview-mirror perspective becomes a persistent and even automatic way of thinking, it presents a real problem.

There are numerous examples of catastrophic thinking in everyday life, such as excessive worry over health issues or occupational failure. Catastrophizing functions as a cognitive distortion that feeds anxiety and depression by overestimating negative outcomes and underestimating coping skills. Consequently, catastrophizers feel anxious and helpless over their perceived inability to manage potential threats.

Luckily, just as events may build up to the extent that they feel catastrophic, so too may they be broken down and reconstructed such that they are no longer viewed as disastrous.

This article has supplied a great deal of valuable information and resources intended to guide readers in stopping catastrophic thinking and instead experience the peace of mind that comes from viewing life through a more realistic and hopeful lens.

We hope you enjoyed reading this article. For more information, don’t forget to download our Positive CBT Exercises for free.